Regular readers of this blog will know that I have a small obsession with author reality shows. It’s the kind of concept that would seem like a complete non-starter–watching authors sit at their desks for hours at a time? Or, alternatively, avoiding sitting at their desks for any time at all? Not exactly riveting viewing. Yet over the past few years, no fewer than five author reality shows have attempted to get off the ground. Let’s recap.
– Book Millionaire. The brainchild of Lori Prokop, owner of her very own vanity press, this show was to feature “Eight people with dreams of seeing their book ideas become published and being the next author launched to best selling and celebrity status.” It never got beyond the video audition stage.
– The Ultimate Author. Created by journalist and self-published author Lauren Spicer, this show promised contestants “go[ing] toe-to-toe in a writing competition that tests their ability to develop attention-grabbing content.” At least one show appears to have been taped, but there’s no sign it was ever broadcast.
– American Book Factory. Four books were to be co-written by teams of authors “competing for what could turn into a major book deal.” This one is dead as a doornail.
– Healeth Publisher. In connection with an Internet TV company, Healeth promised a reality show competition “that will change the publishing game forever.” It’s DOA as well.
– Publish My Book! Proposed by Tony Cowell, Simon Cowell’s brother, this is the only author reality show that seemed even marginally credible. But it fared no better than the rest. Announced for the summer of 2007, it has never appeared.
Five shows; five failures. Nevertheless, a sixth author reality show appears poised for launch: The WRITE Stuff, which, apparently unaware of its predecessors, bills itself as “America’s First Literary Reality Show” (caution: the website features intensely annoying music).
In a history-making reality show hosted by Conversations Book Club President/Publicist Cyrus A. Webb, a total of 14 contestants will be chosen to compete in a contest that will challenge not only their creativity but their drive and determination to make it in the business. Whether their desire is to pursue a career as an author, playwright or spoken word artist, this show will give them the ability to showcase nationally what they are able to do.
Exactly how is not detailed on the website, which provides no info on show formats or schedules. The winner receives a one-book deal and 10 “virtual copies” of their book from AG Press, two years of representation by Cyrus Webb’s Shadow Play Entertainment, and a variety of other stuff, including “a detailed marketing plan,” a Dell laptop, and features in online and print magazines, most of which appear to be ventures owned or operated by Mr. Webb.
Auditions have been conducted and candidates chosen. Judges have been confirmed, some successful commercially-published authors among them. Reading/networking parties are being conducted in various locations. National and local TV channels are being “courted”; the show will also be broadcast on The WRITE Stuff’s YouTube channel. It’s even claimed that the show has entered into a deal with Coca-Cola-owned Vitaminwater, but I can’t find any independent confirmation of this arrangement. (Though The WriteStuff has produced its own YouTube commercial featuring the product, that commercial, interestingly, isn’t listed on the show’s YouTube channel.)
According to the website, the first show is slated to air this June. So will The WRITE Stuff be the one author reality show to actually become, well, real?
This recent article by journalist Adam Lynch, published in the Jackson Free Press, reveals that Cyrus Webb does not exactly have a strong track record when it comes to public events. Lynch reports that in in 2005, a Webb-organized talent show (for which participants had to sell sponsorships), failed to pay the winner the promised prize of $2,000, and rewarded him only with “[a] computer printout…of an award certificate in a cheap frame.”
In 2006, Webb sold $50 tickets for the supposedly exclusive Missisippi’s Best Awards show, but delivered an event with “no celebrities, no food and paltry awards, which Webb printed himself on his personal computer.” (The debacle is discussed in detail in an earlier article by Brian Johnson, and also in a couple of lengthy discussion threads on the Jackson Free Press website, which feature many angry comments from people who attended the show.) As part of the events surrounding the awards show, Webb announced that he was booking several contestants from the hit reality show Project Runway, but the contestants apparently later claimed that he never paid their promised appearance fees and expenses.
Lynch also reports that several of the TV stations that Webb claims as potential markets for The WRITE Stuff deny having any arrangement with him. “We were only aware of the show because the network brought it to our attention, and I made sure we didn’t have it scheduled. If it were to come to our attention, we probably wouldn’t air it because we believe it’s produced without our approval,” says the Vice President of CW69 in Atlanta, Tom Canedo. As of this writing, however, that channel is still listed on Webb’s website.
It also turns out that the show isn’t so much a show as…an infomercial. “When I was on WAPT-16,” Lynch quotes Webb as saying, “I would buy a block of time, and you have 28 minutes and 30 seconds. That’s basically how it works, only instead of selling a blender, it will actually be a show.”
A show with prizes. But what about those prizes? There’s not a lot of info floating around about Webb’s Shadow Play Entertainment, but I can’t discover that it has a significant track record of marketing or promoting books. As for that one-book deal with AG Press…remember the Lanaia Lee Of Atlantis plagiarism uproar? And Lee’s “literary agent,” Cheryl T. Pillsbury? Well, guess who owns AG Press (which, by the way, isn’t really a publisher at all, but a self-publishing service). That’s right: Cheryl T. Pillsbury.
I’ll say this for Cyrus Webb: he’s ambitious. Though The WRITE Stuff hasn’t yet aired, he’s already planning a spinoff…in Nigeria.
UPDATE 11/14/10: Somewhat to my surprise, it appears that several episodes of The WRITE Stuff did air–at least on the show website and YouTube channel (I couldn’t confirm that it ever aired on any of the listed TV stations). The episodes aren’t the contest promised in the initial hype for the show, though–they seem to mostly be Webb in conversation with writers and others about writing-related stuff. So apparently this is another author reality show bust.
Agpress scammed me for 1,100 for a book and marketing. The book is cheap and of course not available anywhere. Cheryl Pillsbury promised to pay royalties for books sold from Oct-2009 – Nov-2010. I never received anything and she tried to blame on me! Agpress has scammed many people and should be out of business. I am out a lot of money and now have to start over. I wish I checked her out before giving her a dime. Worst mistake of my life!
Cheryl here; only reply. Past is done, repaired and over. We have been watching the write stuff and we discovered the shaddy background. We will handle this in our way. Yes we are self publishers and have done quite well.
Ach, this is fork-in-the eye stuff. When will people understand that there are no shortcuts in this industry? There are few Cinderella stories, and those that do exist fuel the thousands who hope lightning strikes in the same place. It doesn’t. Publication is hard business and rather than wasting time on these things, writers should knuckle down and do what they do best. Write.
JP_Fife hit the nail on the head.
This is (was?) about as bad as all the fake “charity” emails that are already coming out of Nigeria.
“Shadow Play Entertainment”? Oh my good Lord.
Trust me–the publishing industry has nothing to do with this or any other author reality show. They exist in an alternate universe.
I don’t know which is in more dire trouble. The Publishing Industry for thinking up “reality shows” like these, or the TV industry who nurtures stupid ideas like this. Great report…thanks
Sounds like a good show idea….for a public access channel.
Cyrus’s World anyone?
He’s planning a spin off in Nigeria? God Bless You Madam, I have many fine novels waiting to be deposited in your account. Send me your bank details to claim your freshly written novels. Remember to tell no one as this is secret.
Anyone described as President/publicist of an organisation should have given pause for thought!
We have a radio show in the UK called The Write Stuff, which is part quiz show part showcase for some tour-de-force pastiche by 4 established writers. It’s been going for years and while hardly a reality show, it does actually live up to its title, unlike Mr Webb.
I wish an author reality show would get off the ground. I mean Fox has done much worse.
We had a celebrity reality show here in the UK on writing a crime novel. It was an interesting format, but a lot of the attention was due to the stars on it having a go at writing.
It was called “Murder Most Famous”. Not sure if you would include this in the category you are discussing above.