Writers Slam Secrecy of Book Publishers’ Deal With Google

American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA.org)
National Writers Union (NWU.org)
Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA.org)

Contacts: Minda Zetlin, President, American Society of Journalists and Authors, 845-481-0252, president@asja.org

Larry Goldbetter: President, National Writers Union, 212-254-0279 x14, 773-551-7021 (cell), larryg601@gmail.com

Michael Capobianco, past President, Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, 301-274-9489, michael@michael-capobianco.com

For Immediate Release:
October 9, 2012

Writers Slam Secrecy of Book Publishers’ Deal with Google; Call on Dept. of Justice to Investigate Antitrust Implications

National writers’ organizations representing authors of books in a variety of genres believe a secret deal between Google and major book publishers may encourage Google to digitize, use, and sell copyrighted books illegally. The writers’ groups ask the Department of Justice to review whether the terms of the secret deal may violate Federal antitrust law.

Google and the Association of American Publishers (AAP) announced October 4 that they had signed a settlement agreement that means the publishers no longer are litigants in an ongoing suit against Google for copyright violations. Since early 2005, Google has been scanning library books for use in its Google Book Search project. Some 20 million books have been scanned, all without permission.

The American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA), the National Writers Union (NWU), and Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) all opposed two attempts to settle the suit — as did the Department of Justice, myriad individual authors, organizations, Attorneys General of many states, and even foreign governments. We now stand with the Authors Guild in believing Google violated authors’ copyrights. This new, secret settlement with Google may do writers further damage.

We call on publishers to make the settlement terms public: which books are included, and how much money is changing hands?

“Writers are partners with publishers in the joint venture of royalty publishing. We are contractually entitled to full disclosure of a deal that affects our books, rights, royalties, and livelihoods,” said ASJA President Minda Zetlin.

We have written to the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice today to ask that they re-open their investigation of this case, and review the terms of the settlement for possible violations of federal law.

“Settlement negotiations should not be allowed to serve as a cover for otherwise-impermissible collusion by parties to litigation against the interests of other stakeholders, such as the writers of these books, who were excluded from those negotiations,” said NWU President Larry Goldbetter.

Copyright law declares the creator of a work retains all rights not spelled out in the publishing contract. Until very recently, book contracts had no language whatever about e-books or digital rights. So when a publisher agrees to give Google access to its backlist of books, it’s very likely that the publisher is taking money for rights it doesn’t own. The authors own them.

Our organizations believe many publishers, including some of those who settled, have been engaged in the systematic theft of writers’ electronic rights and e-book revenues where digital rights were never assigned by authors to publishers. They have been licensing e-book editions of works to which they hold only print rights. The industry needs an open process whereby authors can challenge  ownership of any rights in question.

Whether Google Can Legally Copy Millions of Books Is Still in Question

With 20 million books already scanned, Google continues scanning books daily. In The Authors Guild, Inc. et al. v. Google, now before the U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, writers say this is illegal, since those who hold the rights to the books haven’t given permission. Whether the publishers’ settlement with Google will affect the lawsuit is unclear.

We are concerned that this new, secret agreement will give Google erstwhile permission to ramp up its illegal scanning. Even for those books to which publishers can legitimately license e-book rights, many questions remain. The secrecy of the deal lends itself to abuses.

ASJA, NWU, and SFWA urge Google, the AAP, and the publisher litigants to do the right thing: disclose the complete terms of this settlement immediately. If the parties won’t do so voluntarily, the Department of Justice needs to use its authority to investigate this agreement.


  1. Some more very bad news for authors. The Hathi Trust has been amassing all the Google scans to distribute among all the members of this large library consortium and thence to the public. They were sued, and the Hathi Trust won. See http://www.laboratorium.net.

  2. Also see this:


    Note that although Google's PR announced that they are concerned about so-called orphan works, they scanned enormous numbers of in-print books with locatable authors and publishers. These entities may do much the same thing, and in fact Google has given money to various European scanning projects.

    Also note that if the owner of the work cannot be identified (and I am not at all confident searches would be truly diligent), that owner could easily be American.

    And, ALSO note that free giveaways of your work by nonprofit entities are likely to considerably undercut your paid sales. They are not in your interest.

  3. I see this declaration as a solid piece of reporting and don't see any reason why the court would not act on our behalf – other than the fact that the courts are in collusion with the publishers and Google – and are accepting BRIBES If that statement puts me at risk for litigation, then so be it. I welcome the courts to prove otherwise.
    Morgen Marshall
    Knoxville, TN

  4. I see no scenario where authors win anything. The major players will slice up the entire pie for themselves. Authors may see a few pennies in trickle down.

    Google is big enough to steal nearly every book ever written and the big publishers will let them do it in exchange for a piece of the action.

Leave a Reply

OCTOBER 5, 2012

Publishers Settle With Google–But What About Authors?

OCTOBER 12, 2012

Judge Rules Against Authors Guild in HathiTrust Lawsuit